Coat Check Coffee

Edward York 3 months ago

Stopped by based off reviews. I asked for the drink that best represents their coffee shop and got their butterscotch latte. I was a little worried it would be too sweet, but it was delicious! You can taste the butterscotch but it isn’t overwhelming and the touch of cinnamon on top adds a nice layer of extra flavor. Would definitely recommend! Side note, it’s located within the theater building. I was a little unsure at first as I didn’t notice any signage outside.

Morgan Pizzuti 4 months ago

Coffee place in cool Athenaeum. Could definitely miss this spot if you’re not looking for it. The lighting in the seating area is dark and the space feels kinda random/not clearly delineated from the rest of the building (shared with other businesses). Coffee was good but pricey especially for their specialty lattes. Best for on the go I would say.

Amanda Dolph (Indyapple) 8 months ago

If heaven had a coffee bar, it would taste like Coat Check Coffee! ☕️✨ I ordered the butterscotch latte and a brown butter chocolate chip cookie with salt, and wow—perfection from the first sip to the last crumb. The latte was smooth, creamy, and perfectly balanced—not too sweet, just that cozy butterscotch richness that makes you want to linger a little longer. And that cookie? Absolute bliss. Soft in the middle, crisp at the edges, with that touch of salt that makes every bite addictive. Between the warm, welcoming vibe and the quality of everything they serve, Coat Check Coffee has officially earned a spot on my favorites list. Highly recommend stopping in—you won’t regret it! 💛

Kara Gladish 2 weeks ago

The butterscotch latte was even better than I expected - not too sweet and with complex flavors. And my biscuit breakfast sandwich was unreal. I will be back! I want to try all the signature lattes. Also nice that there's a elevator if you go in the Rathskeller entrance.

Hinal Patel a year ago

This spot works well as a casual workspace for quick meetings. The atmosphere is welcoming, with cozy corners ideal for focused work. While slightly pricier than average, the quality of the food justifies the cost. My standout favorite was the butterscotch latte—a perfect balance of sweet and salty, with just the right amount of sweetness. For breakfast, the bacon breakfast sandwich is worth trying. Though the biscuit base isn’t the best, the bacon is crispy and flavorful. The egg soufflé stole the show: impossibly fluffy and moist, it’s a must-try